The Cheapest, Bestest Gaming PC Submitted Friday, September 5, 2008 - 1:41:04 PM by Klaitu
It seems like it's new computer buying season, I know at least 3 people who are considering buying a new machine for gaming and for school or business. So, since there's interest, I shall write out my tips for getting the most bang for your buck.
In order to do that, I'm going to disregard laptops. They're expensive if you want one that can also play games.
To illustrate how to do this, I'm going to use http://www.ibuypower.com as my example. I like them, but some people don't. You don't have to buy from them though, I'm only using them as an example of how to get the most value.
Please, open ibuypower.com in another window and follow along, class!
Choices, Choices.
The first choice we need to make is processor. We can choose Intel Core 2 Duo, Intel Quad Core, or AMD Athlon X2.
What's the difference? Intel processors are generally higher quality than AMD processors, and the Intel Quad Core is actually 4 processors built into one chip.. pretty powerful stuff. Intel chips are also more expensive than AMD.
For this example, we're going to choose AMD Athlon X2, because games don't generally use the extra features that Intel offers. It's cheaper, and it works for our needs.
The next choice we get to make is the case design. Because we're on ibuypower, they have tested all these cases and none of them are bad, however there are bad cases out in the real world. The main concern with the case is ventilation, and the secondary concern is space. You want lots of both.
For this example, we'll chose the ATX basic case. It's the cheapest case, probably because it isn't particularly good looking.. but hey, whatever works, right?
The next option is for neon lights.. pass on that one.
Now we are to the power supply. This is an important decision, and it depends on how much power you need. The main sucker of power in a gaming computer is the video card, but your drives will also be plugged into this thing.
For this example, we're going to go with the 500 watt power supply. We don't know what kind of power supply comes with the case, so if it's not enough juice, we're screwed. 500 watts is plenty enough for what we're doing.
Now it's time to pick the processor. AMD is stupid in how they market their processors and they will not tell you the clock speed of the processors. The more money you spend here, the faster your processor will be. If you want to spring for it, I recommend the AMD Phenom x4, it's not terribly expensive, but it's a quad core processor.
For this example, we're going to go with the AMD x2 5400, as it gives us the most advantage for the price, and we're trying to be cheap.
Now, the free software section, since it's free, pick whatever you want.
Processor Cooling selection. Unless you're planning on overclocking, the default choice is probably fine. If you're not sure what overclocking is, then you're good with the standard fan and heatsink.
The next selection is motherboard, there are a lot of choices here, but since you're on ibuypower, you could safely pick any of these. However, in the real world there are bad motherboards, so beware.
The main thing you need to decide here is if you might upgrade your computer in the future with more than one video card. If you think that might happen one day, then choose something that says "SLI" or "crossfire" on it.
For this example, we're going with the Asus M2N-SLI motherboard.
Next is RAM. They give you a lot of selections here, but here's a secret: it doesn't matter all that much. The more RAM you can have, the better. Anything at 2 gigs are above is going to work out great for you. Just so you know, you see where it says DDR2-800 on some, and DDR2-1066 on others? The 1066 RAM is faster and "better", but is also more expensive, and doesn't offer that much better results.
So, for this example we are going with the basic 2 GB DDR2-800. The brand doesn't matter much here, I picked the value brand.
Video Card!
For a gaming machine, this is the single most important component in the computer. There are jillions of kinds of video cards out there, and you can generally figure "the more expensive, the better it is" but that's not always true.
This is the one part of the computer that you can't skimp on.
First you need to decide if you want ATI or Nvidia. Myself, I like Nvidia, and I am not fond of ATI.
The best card on the list at the time of this writing is the GeForce GTX 280 1GB, so if you can afford it, go for it. This card is an absolute powerhouse.. but you do have other options.
The best video card on this list that gives you performance and value is the GeForce 9800GTX+ 512MB, it's nearly 300 bucks cheaper than the GeForce 280. In fact, it's such a good buy that we're going to make that our choice for the example.
Video Card manufacturer, I could go into details on why people might care about that, but I won't. Suffice to say, go with the cheapest option.
Hard Drives
This is a matter of how much storage you want. You can more or less ignore the rest of the stats.. however you DO want to get a hard drive here, because these are Serial ATA drives, which is a newer technology, and it's unlikely that your old computer has compatible drives. Plus, ibuypower is going to install windows for you if you've got a hard drive.
For this example, we're going with the cheapest drive possible. Because there's a special right now, that's a 320 GB drive, but you might end up with a 160.
Why? Because hard drives are cheap. If you need more space you can always go later on and get an external USB drive, they make them in enormous sizes and they're a good value.
There's also the possiblity that you can slap the hard drive from your present computer into this new one, it's not hard.
2nd Hard Drive.. pass.
External Hard Drives.. pass.
CD/DVD drive.. pass.
CD-RW/DVD-RW Drive, okay, here's where we get tricky. If you want to burn CD's, then you need this. However, if your present computer already has this, you can put that one in your new computer and save money.
For this example, we're assuming you already have one and we're going to pass on the drive.
Sound Card.. pass.
Speakers, Floppy Drive.. pass
Okay, now we're to monitor selection. The monitor you are reading this with right now will work fine with your new computer, so there is no need to get a monitor here. However, if you're looking to upgrade your monitor, this may be a good time to do it. Of course, you could wait and buy a monitor from an electronics store where you can see the screens and compare their picture.
For our example, we'll assume you are going to use your present monitor.
2nd Monitor.. pass
Keyboard, Mouse.. pass (you already have them!)
USB Accessories, Meter Display, Flash Writer, Extras.. pass.
Finally, now we are to the Operating System. The best value here is Windows Vista Home Basic 32 bit.. and people like to yell about Vista, so I will explain why this is the best choice!
Firstly, you just spent a great deal of money on a video card, a video card that was designed specifically to work with Windows Vista. It will work with Windows XP, but you'll be missing features that the card was designed to do.
Secondly, Windows XP is more expensive now. Microsoft wants you to buy Vista, and that's alright because for your new computer, Vista is better in every way.
People have asked me about Vista 64-bit, to which I say "not yet". Vista 64 allows you to install more RAM into your computer, but Vista 64 is much slower than Vista 32, and at this point there is no need to go to 64 on a gaming machine.
At any rate, our example is going to use Vista Basic 32, and if yours doesn't, you're only kidding yourself.
Everything after the Operating System.. pass.
So, let's look at what we've created: We've got a powerful computer with dual cores, a good amount of RAM, and an excellent video card. This computer will run WoW without even blinking. It will run LOTRO on ultra settings effortlessly. It will even run Age of Conan smoothly.. and if it can do that, think of what it will do for older games like Portal or Oblivion.
The total component cost of our example was $793. With the shipping, that gets pumped up to $892 (stupid gas prices).
Let's compare with Dell!
First off, you can't configure their value PC's with nvidia graphics cards. The best ATI card you can get is the HD3870/512, which is considered a "budget card" and is not half as powerful as the 9800GTX we configured earlier.
The price on this Dell computer? 1,049 before shipping.
So, what if we really want an nvidia card with dell, how much will that cost us? Well, we have to go up a tier in Dell's price model, so if we wanted the nvidia budget card (which isn't as powerful as that ATI one we just did) it's $1,199 before shipping.
Okay, so what if we got extreme.. we absolutely must have a card that is as good or better than the card we picked with ibuypower!
The cheapest nvidia card that dell offers that is also better than the 9800gtx is the geforce 280 GTX (that's the one we considered at ibuypower, but was too expensive). the price of the dell system with this card in it, and everything else stripped down as much as possible is $2,099 before shipping.
Now, Dell's computer is not an exact match for our ibuypower computer, it's got more hard drive space, 1 GB more RAM, and an Intel Quad Core processor, it also comes with speakers, keyboard, and a mouse, and an optical drive.
What does this mean in terms of performance? The Dell computer will start up faster, and it will get through loading screens on games faster. Graphics performance during a game will be slightly better on the Dell system.
Now, the question you have to ask yourself: Would I rather pay $892, or $2,099? Are slightly faster load times and only slightly better graphics performance worth $1,100?
Nay, I say!
Now, we used ibuypower for our example, but you don't have to do that. You could buy all of the parts we picked out individually and assemble them yourself and you might save 50 bucks or so. If you've got a computer hobby shop in your area, you can save even more since you won't have to pay for shipping.
So, have you been dreaming of an awesome gaming computer, but could never afford it? I'll bet you just got a little closer.
Technical Details with LOTRO? (Most people who asked me about this are LOTRO players)
3GB of RAM, GeForce 8800 GTX, Vista Premium, LOTRO DX10, Ultra settings: 79.3 FPS average (This system is less affected by high quality antialiasing than the others)
2GB of RAM, GeForce 9800 GTX, Vista Basic, LOTRO DX10, Ultra settings: 91.2 FPS average (This system is the most affected by antialiasing and post-processing effects)
2GB of RAM, GeForce 280 GTX, Vista Basic, LOTRO DX10, Ultra settings: 99.7 FPS average (This thing is just a beast)
All systems have Athlon X2 5400 processor (2.8 ghz). All tests at 1680 by 1050 resolution.
|