Superman Returns Submitted Friday, July 7, 2006 - 2:38:26 AM by Klaitu
Mixed Feelings here.. also spoilers, so if you're not into that kinda thing, like.. look away.
Let's look at this movie from a pros/cons sort of perspective..
Pros
- Nice visual effects. They're finally getting to an era where the effects work is not readily obvious.. most of the time. The Plane Rescue sequence is particularly nice.
- Very well acted. Special Props to whatever kid played young clark!
- Preservation of Original Superman Theme / 3D logos. Little heavy on the astronomical wonders in the credits, but so was the original.
- Nice music! Sorry, John Ottman, it was good, but the original was better.
- Although the movie is almost 3 hours long, it never drags. I heard someone say this on the radio, and they're right. I never felt the need to nap.
- Marlon Brando as Jor El! You just can't beat that. Best Jor El ever.
Cons - Discontinuity! This is a BIG one. In Superman Returns, he's supposedly gone for 5 years. The only problem is that when Superman left, it was 1979. Now it's 2006. 5 years? This just doesn't make sense! There are more continuity glitches, but one big one is..
- Super Boy? Dear Bryan Singer, WTF? Love, Klaitu.
Never you mind the fact that Superman and Lois never did the hokey pokey.. nor the fact that she was older in 1979 than she is in 2006.. but c'mon, it's Superman. He should have gotten married first.. just because that's what Superman does. He's wholesome!
- Goofy Lex. Lex in the original Supes movie was pretty goofy. He ran around with morons who would always get him into trouble.. sure enough, he's doing it again. I much prefer brilliant scheming millionaire Lex to silly bumbling delusional Lex.
The Bottom Line:
Superman Returns is a pretty good movie. It's worth watching, worth spending money on, and worth your time.. however, it does not live up to all that a Superman movie should. Not even the original could do that, although it came close.
And really, if you thought that "travel back in time" was pretty big crap, wait until you see the "burrow into the earth and throw a giant island into orbit" scene. That's a little weak, too.
Overall Score: 7 of 10.
|