Top 5 "WTF?" Moments in Television Submitted Friday, April 4, 2008 - 4:22:36 PM by Klaitu
Or, if you prefer "When good writers get bad crack".
There is some matter of taste with any form of art, such as television. Then there's stuff that just doesn't make any sense at all. It's usually because the show has jumped the shark, and instead of going out on its own terms, it has plodded along and been milked for all it was worth.
Here then are my top 5 examples of writers just sorta going crazy with their various TV shows.
5. The X-Files
Most people have heard of the X-Files. FBI agent and paranormal investigator Fox Mulder tries to track down evidence of the supernatural with his skeptic sidekick, Scully.
By nature of the show, strange things happened. Scully was abducted by aliens at least 2 times during the show's run, but still remained a skeptic. The x-Files led us through a world of government conspiracies, and aliens lurking around every corner.
During the 8th season, David Duchovny decided he had spent enough time on the X-Files, and started reducing his commitment to the show. During the 9th season, he was completely absent.. except for the series finale.
So, what's a writer to do? The star of the show isn't on the show anymore.. and you don't have an ensemble cast, you've got two main characters. Well, I'm getting ahead of myself, as the show had already gone and jumped the shark.
Scully was pregnant. Being the X-Files, she can't JUST be pregnant, it's got to be an alien, or something. It doesn't end there, though. Throughout the series it is established that Scully is infertile and cannot produce children. She becomes pregnant anyway because she was implanted with an alien device that apparently "triggered" and made her pregnant.
Yes, its weird.. NO, it doesn't stop there! They went for the gold! The father is Fox Mulder! WTF!??!?
Fox Mulder has somehow impregnated an infertile woman (without his knowledge, mind you) via the use of a biological implant from aliens.
Scully spends the 9th season looking for Mulder, the father of her.. alien baby?
WTF indeed.
4. Dallas
I wasn't a big Dallas watcher, but they created such a colossal WTF moment, that everyone has heard of it. Not only did this show "Shoot J.R." it also killed Patrick Duffy.
Patrick Duffy had decided not to stay on Dallas. Apparently people actually liked Patrick Duffy in 1985, because the viewers didn't want him gone. The people desired Patrick Duffy! The ratings proved it, when Duffy left the show, the ratings plummeted. They begged Duffy to return.. and eventually Duffy agreed.
Slight problem: Duffy's character had died.. and not just any questionable death. He had died in a hospital, with little monitors going "Beep beep... beeeeeeeee", and to top things off, he was shown in a casket, dead.. in a funeral attended by just about every other character on the show. There's no way around it, he was dead.
Short of zombies (which might actually have been interesting) how do you get the actor back in when the character is dead? Do you make him an evil twin? Do you make him a long lost cousin? Dallas came up with something different: Patrick Duffy's death (and also, the 31 episodes after his death) were revealed to be the nightmare of his on-screen lover.
Essentially, the writing rendered an entire season of Dallas to be nonexistant, and the story was reset at a point just before Duffy died, leading Dallas fans around the world to exclaim "WTF?!?!?!"
3. Magnum P.I.
Tom Selleck had a similar problem. People just couldn't get enough of HIM either. He decided he didn't want to continue with Magnum P.I. In the 7th season Finale, Tom Selleck was shot and killed by mobsters.
Before the episode aired, word leaked out about the plot and America want crazy-go-nuts. They had to have more Tom Selleck, so they threw a buncha money at him, and Selleck agreed to come back.
Season 8 of Magnum PI practically ignores the whole death thing, though his death was not as elaborate as that of Patrick Duffy, and they also didn't "reset" the show. They just sort of pretended it never happened.
As much as I'd like to say WTF here, not many people really noticed the death thing, and ir just sort of remains unsolved.
2. Star Trek: Voyager
I'm a big Star Trek fan, and even I can't come up with a remotely plausible reason for this one.
Star Trek Voyager's premise was that a Star Trek crew was stuck in the distant reaches of the galaxy, stranded far from home. The story arc of the series had them trying to get home in pretty much every episode.. and in the finale, they actually do get home. Twice. Sort of.
Now, the Voyager finale has a lot of writing problems. At least two dozen of them of differing degrees of severity. It's got a time travel element that renders the first 45 minutes of the episode irrelevant, for instance, but that's not the WTF moment.
Voyager's return to Earth involved it flying inside a "transwarp conduit" controlled by the Borg. The Borg don't like Voyager all that much, so they want to blow it up. Voyager is racing down the conduit, a borg ship in hot pursuit.. it's going to catch them at any moment!
The next scene shows this borg ship emerging from the transwarp conduit, where a bunch of Starfleet ships promptly blow it up.. and out of the explosion comes Voyager... WTF?!?!?!?!
How did Voyager get inside the Borg ship? It hardly seems large enough to hold Voyager. Aside from which, how did Voyager withstand the explosion of the ship around it? Why was it that close to begin with? Why make it so confusing?
WTF, Voyager people?!?
1. Andromeda
All of those shows above make perfect sense when compared to Gene Roddenberry's Andromeda. Its writers were obviously on some sort of drugs. The plot of Andromeda is something that might make sense to someone stoned out of their mind.
Andromeda is another case where it was Cancelled and then saved from cancellation after the finale.
Season 4 ends with ALL of the major characters dying. Not just dying a little, dying "for reals". Things like being decapitated.. piloting a ship that explodes.. One of the characters literally EXPLODES. The Andromeda (the ship) is engulfed in a sun and explodes, and destroys the bad guys ship. So, all main characters dead, ship destroyed.
The Captain doesn't die, he escapes to a place called the "route of ages". It's a dark room where he sees himself, smiles, and turns around and walks the other way.
Then the credits roll.
WTF?!?
Oh, but I'm just beginning!
Season 5 makes even less sense! You know how everyone died? They're not dead anymore, and the Andromeda ship is still around (after being engulfed in a sun) and the big bad guy ship it destroyed, turns out it was only "damaged" (despite the fact that it exploded into a bunch of tiny pieces on the screen). Also, the Captain is now some sort of supernatural God being, and Earth explodes for apparently no reason.
WTF??!!?
Maybe it's best not to dwell on such things.
|