Stupid X3 Submitted Monday, October 6, 2008 - 2:30:45 PM by Klaitu
You know what really grinds my gears?
X-Men: The Last Stand
I recently re-watched the movie, and I have to say that while it has some good points, it also has some serious problems.
First off, all of a sudden, everyone is flying everywhere. Storm flies in the first 5 minutes of the movie.. but Jean Grey also flies, Angel flies, and Magneto flies later on..
Sure, they all can fly in the comic books, but the movies have firmly established this "no flying" policy. In the first movie, Magneto is able to levitate since he is on top of the Statue of Liberty. Later, Storm and Jean Grey are able to "fly" Wolverine up to the torch, though this process is not stable at all.
In the second film, Magneto temporarily levitates when he's inside a large metal room. He is also able to levitate himself out of prison with the aid of a metal disc. Other than that, there is no flying.. and there's a very good reason: Flying looks stupid in a live-action movie unless you do it a very specific way.
Secondly, the movie's character choices were less than stellar. Some of them didn't make any sense at all.
The biggest problem is that the filmmakers basically cut Rogue out of the movie, and instead replaced her role with that of Shadowcat. Now, Iceman and Shadowcat are romantically linked.. except this is out of character, Shadowcat has always been linked with Colossus, and never with Iceman. However, Rogue and Iceman have been linked from time to time.. so at least that makes sense.
This leads me to the next problem: Rogue is all screwed up.. and this isn't X3's fault, neccessarily. Rogue was screwed up since the beginning of the films. The main problem is that Rogue is not a teenager. They've sort of made her the "newcomer" through which the audience is able to see Xavier's School, but that role doesn't belong to her. In the 1980's, that role belonged to Shadowcat. In the 1990's, that role belonged to Jubilee. Rogue is older than both Jubilee and Shadowcat. You can't make her into a teenager without wrecking her whole character points.
Speaking of character points, in X3, Rogue takes "the cure" and becomes a "normal human". This is something that she considers in the comics, but decides against once she realizes that she can help people with her abilities.
And speaking of Abilities, where are the other half of Rogues powers? Sure she can absorb other mutant's powers, but in the comics her body is indestructable, she can fly, and shes strong enough to do things like lift cars. She obtained these abilities from Ms. Marvel in her youth, and the struggle between Rogue and the latent imprint of Ms. Marvel is a huuuge point of Rogue's story.
And what's the deal with Rogue telling Wolverine her name is "Marie". Nobody knows Rogue's real name except Rogue, and she's never told anyone.. the only person she wanted to tell was Gambit, who told her to keep it to herself.
I don't mind them changing stuff around for a movie, but they should at least not wreck the characters.
It's not just Rogue who is screwed up, though.. Magneto got the shaft as well. Magneto commonly gets the shaft since he gets pigeonholed as the "X-Men villain" but he's really a decent guy who sees the Human race as a group of bullies who want to destroy mutants.. to that end he favors wiping them out before they develop the means to do the same to him.
This much is portrayed in the films, but they give Magneto a much more sinister, evil intent. In the first film, he's portrayed well.. he wants to mutate the world leaders so that mutants won't have to fight humans. In the second movie he wants Xavier to use Cerebro 2 to kill all the humans at once, leaving only mutants. In the third movie he... just wants to fight people. He literally raises an army and tries to start a war between humans and mutants.
Also out of character is Magneto abandoning Mystique once she gets hit with "the cure". This is something that Magneto would never do, he treats his followers well and that's why they devote themselves to him. They are literally Magneto's Acolytes.
Another problem? The death of Professor X. Magneto and Xavier are old friends.. and not like "once upon a time" old friends, they are friends who are so close that they are like brothers. In the comics, the death of Professor X was so astounding, and such a big deal that Magneto renounced his conflict with humanity and dedicated his life to Xavier's ideals. He even led the X-men. In the film, their relationship gets one line "Charles Xavier did more for mutants than you will ever know". That's it.
There are also serious problems with minor characters in the movie.
Leech isn't green. Is that a big deal? Well, what if beast wasn't blue, or Nightcrawler wasn't scarred?
Callisto's powers are wrong. Sure, she can sense mutants, but now she can.. run real fast?
Psylocke's powers are completely wrong. In the movie she turns invisible. However, Psylockes power is the psionic dagger and the butterfly effect. She's also british, which she isn't in the movie.
Arclight is sort of right. In the movie, she can.. clap really loud. In the comics she can create shockwaves from her hands (not really from clapping). She also has strength like Rogue is supposed to have.
Pyro's powers are correct, but he doesn't really use them in this movie at all. Also, Pyro is austrailian, a fact that is left out of the movie entirely.
Juggernaut.. well, he's not a mutant. He's Professor X's brother.. and aside from that, the movie says "The prisoner can't be allowed to gain momentum, if he does he will become unstoppable". Problem: He was in a moving truck 5 minutes ago.. he had momentum (if you're just disregaring the momentum he has from just being on Earth... which is moving)
Thirdly, the actual movie itself is poorly made. Do you recall what happens to leech once he is rescued by Shadowcat? Of course you don't, the movie doesn't say!
What about Angel? He was featured prominently in the trailer and his character is actually portrayed correctly. Oh wait, we see him for about 5 seconds.
The movie tries to do too much and ends up not delivering.
I can't stay mad at X3 for very long, because it does a few things exactly right. One of those things is Beast.
Casting Kelsey Grammer as Beast was the most perfect choice of casting in any movie ever. Kelsey Grammer IS Beast. Beast's makeup was great, he moved like beast, he talked like beast, his lines were things that beast would say. His internal conflict was exactly like it should have been. The portrayal of Beast was absolutely perfect.
Storm sucks.. It's nothing to do with the movie, but Storm has always sucked. Her character sucks, she never has anything interesting to say, her powers suck, she dresses funny, and nobody really likes her.. but she's been in the x-men since forever, and it wouldn't be the X-men without her.
Likewise, Hallie Berry sucks. She can't act, isn't pretty, isn't interesting, and when she's on screen you want to take a nap because she sucks. She's an absolute shoe-in for Storm, and the casting here was perfect.
Anyways, that's today's X-men rant.
|